Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly (Love Letters #2) – Love Letters, Lost Time, and a Second Chance Romance

Hey babes, have you ever had that one person who just got away? The one who, even years later, still lingers in your mind? Well, buckle up because Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly takes that classic “the one that got away” and makes it unforgettable. This book had me laughing, tearing up, and, honestly, swooning over every bit of Rosie and Nate’s reconnection.

Trigger Warnings: Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly touches on themes of abuse and emotional trauma, also murder so be prepared for some heart-tugging moments.

Books in the series:

Love, Utley
Dear Rosie

Plot Summary of Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly

When we meet Rosie Edwards, she’s crafted a peaceful life as the proud owner of a thriving catering business, carefully piecing herself back together after a painful past. But all that hard-won peace shatters when she finds herself catering an event face-to-face with Nathan Waller—her childhood best friend, long-lost first love, and now a retired NFL star. The twist? Nathan doesn’t recognise her.

Nathan feels an instant pull toward Rosie, unaware of their shared history. After one steamy, unforgettable moment in the pantry, everything comes flooding back to him. From that moment, he’s determined to rekindle what they once shared—and more. But as they navigate this explosive second chance at love, buried secrets threaten to turn everything upside down.

The letters from their past, a misunderstood goodbye, and hidden truths that could unravel everything hang over them, threatening to pull them apart just when they’ve finally found each other again. Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly is a journey of rekindling passion, healing, and daring to trust again, but with secrets that could easily shatter them both.

This book is packed with juicy tropes like:

• Childhood friends-to-strangers-to-lovers
• Plus-size FMC with ALL the confidence
• Millionaire romance
• Retired athlete
• Emotional damage (you’ll need tissues, babes)

Character Development

Rosie? She’s an absolute treasure. Having faced the emotional turmoil of her childhood, she’s emerged with incredible resilience and strength. Though her past has left its marks, she’s anything but broken. Her journey is one of rediscovering how to love and trust again, especially when it comes to Nathan—someone who inadvertently caused her pain. Watching her navigate her emotions in Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly and gradually open her heart to the possibility of rekindled love is both heartwarming and empowering.

Nathan, on the other hand, has lived a life steeped in privilege and fame as a former NFL star. It’s not that he forgot Rosie out of spite; life simply swept him along a different path, leaving him blissfully unaware of the impact his departure had on her. However, once their past collides with their present, and he realises the depth of their connection, he dives headfirst into making things right.

Witnessing Nate’s transformation from a man who was oblivious to the weight of his actions into someone fiercely devoted to Rosie is a joy to behold. His journey—from not recognising her to declaring, “I won’t let you go”—is a testament to love’s power and the beauty of second chances, making their romance all the more compelling.

Themes and Messages

Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly explores the profound themes of second chances and the healing power of love. It delves into the complexities of childhood bonds, illustrating how relationships that were once broken can be painstakingly mended over time.
This story captures the essence of acceptance and forgiveness, highlighting the journey of rediscovering oneself and the importance of reconnecting with those who have always held a special place in our hearts—even when they’ve been absent. It beautifully illustrates that sometimes the most meaningful connections can weather the storm of time and distance, reminding us that love can transcend the past and pave the way for a brighter future.

Writing Style and Tone

S.J. Tilly has a masterful way of weaving together humour, intensity, and romance, creating a reading experience that feels both immersive and entertaining. Her writing flows effortlessly, striking the perfect balance of detail to draw you into each emotional moment without overwhelming you.

The dialogue in Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly sparkles with wit, making every exchange between Rosie and Nate a delight, while the chemistry between them is simply *chef’s kiss*. Tilly excels at portraying Rosie’s vulnerability alongside her resilience, crafting a character who feels relatable and real.
Meanwhile, she gives Nate just the right amount of depth, allowing readers to fully appreciate his growth and transformation throughout the story. It’s a captivating blend that makes for an unforgettable romantic journey.

Emotional Impact

Critical Analysis

Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly shines with its strengths, particularly in character depth, chemistry, and brilliantly crafted banter. Rosie and Nate’s connection feels raw and authentic, brimming with just the right amount of angst to keep you thoroughly hooked. The pacing of the story is spot-on, allowing the reader to truly appreciate Nate’s transformation from “stranger” to a fully devoted partner without feeling rushed.
Despite it becoming full-on, quite quickly. Their interactions crackle with energy, making every moment between them a delight.

However, I found myself yearning for a deeper glimpse into Nate’s inner thoughts during their initial reconnection. I wanted to hear more about his reflections on the years apart and how he grappled with the emotions that resurfaced upon seeing Rosie again.
This would have added an even richer layer to his character, but it’s honestly a minor quibble in an otherwise incredible story. The strengths of this book—its character depth and the palpable chemistry between Rosie and Nate—make it a truly engaging read that left me utterly satisfied.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly is the kind of heartwarming romance that lingers in your thoughts long after the final page. It’s the perfect blend of sweetness and spice, capturing the essence of second chances with a depth that resonates deeply. For anyone who adores emotional journeys and profound connections, this story is an absolute must-read.

The way it intertwines angst with tender, heart-melting moments creates an experience that is not just enjoyable but transformative. And let’s not forget about Charles, the charming cat who adds an extra layer of warmth and whimsy to the narrative—he quickly became my favourite character!

If you’re ready to be swept away by a tale of love, healing, and rediscovery (with a sprinkle of feline charm), then Dear Rosie should be at the top of your reading list. Trust me, this beautiful story will leave you feeling all the feels and wishing for more.

Ratings

• Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)
• Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️ (3/5) – Steamy, intense, and oh-so-good!
• Violence Level: 🗡️ (1/5) – Minimal violence
• Emotional Depth: 💧💧💧💧 (4/5) – High on feels
• Dark Content: 🌑🌑 (2/5) – Touches on some deep themes, but nothing too heavy
• Character Development: 🧑‍🤝‍🧑🧑‍🤝‍🧑🧑‍🤝‍🧑 (3/5) – Solid growth, especially Rosie’s journey
• Pacing: ⏳⏳⏳⏳ (4/5) – Quick, engaging, never drags
• Writing Style: ✍️✍️✍️✍️ (4/5) – Engaging and smooth
• Themes: 🏷️🏷️🏷️🏷️ (4/5) – Deep and relatable themes
• Chemistry: ❤️❤️❤️❤️ (4/5) – Spark-flying chemistry between Nate and Rosie
• Humour Level: 😂😂 (2/5) – Some fun moments but leans more emotional

Favourite Quotes

Discussion Points 

• How do you feel about childhood friends reconnecting as adults?
• Did Nate’s initial forgetfulness change your perception of him?
• Which scene had you reaching for tissues?

Why Read Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly?

If you’re in the mood for a second-chance romance that brings emotional depth with a side of steam, then Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly needs to be on your shelf. It’s a love story with all the feels and just the right amount of spice to keep things interesting. This one’s going to stay with you long after you turn the last page.

Discover Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly on Amazon Kindle Unlimited! Enjoy a free 30-day trial by clicking here.

I purchased Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly myself, and my review is based on my genuine thoughts and experiences with the book, whether I read it or accessed it through Kindle Unlimited.

Fancy listening to the hot and steamy book instead? Try the audiobook on Audible instead! It’s a convenient way to enjoy the captivating story while you’re multitasking or on the go. Immerse yourself in the narrative hands-free by starting your free 30 day trial here!

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please note that links included within this post include Amazon Affiliate links and I earn a small commission for purchases through these links.

Dear Rosie, by S.J. Tilly
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly is everything I crave in a romance—heartfelt, emotional, and a touch spicy! This is a beautiful second-chance story about Rosie, a resilient and independent caterer, and Nathan, her childhood best friend turned NFL superstar, who accidentally reunite after years apart.

When they bump into each other at an event, Rosie recognises him immediately, but Nathan? Not so much. One steamy pantry encounter later, he remembers everything, and from that moment on, he’s all in, determined not to let her slip away again. The chemistry between Rosie and Nate is pure fire, and their connection feels both natural and intense—a combination that kept me turning the pages all night.

Rosie’s journey is one of healing and self-acceptance, and Nate’s growth from a guy who didn’t realise what he’d lost to one who is fully committed is so satisfying to watch. The letters from Rosie that she had are a nostalgic touch, bringing both sweetness and a little bit of heartache to their reunion.

The only thing I wished for was a bit more backstory on Nate’s thoughts during their years apart, but even without that, this story packs a major emotional punch. And let’s not forget Charles the cat, who steals every scene he’s in—such a fun addition to the story!

If you love second-chance romances with a perfect blend of angst, humour, and romance, Dear Rosie by SJ Tilly is a must-read. This book will tug at your heartstrings, make you laugh, and maybe even bring a tear or two to your eye. Highly recommend! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

View all my reviews